JEAN-LUC MARION’S VEIL OF “THE ‘END OF METAPHYSICS’”. TOWARDS AN INDETERMINATE EXCESS OF SATURATION AND DEFICIENCE IN PHENOMENOLOGY
DOI: http://dx.doi.org/10.30970/vps.20.2018.12
Abstract
Who or what comes to light after the ‘beyond’ of Cartesian, Husserlian or Heideggerian post-intuitus philosophical attempts and receives a new souffl e (breath) from otherwise JeanLuc Marion’s desire to opt conceptually a new context for phenomenological and theological researches? Granted the importance of René Descartes, Edmund Husserl and Martin Heidegger, it is, nevertheless, Jean-Luc Marion who has contributed to the question of overcoming of metaphysics’ possibility in order to disqualify a ground of being within a phenomenological reality of love. In the present article the author wishes to introduce an acquaintance of Jean-Luc Marion’s pensée (thinking) in reference to the inevitability of the leap through metaphysics aiming at doing justice to Ukrainian readers by putting Marion’s voice into the nuance of new approaches that have been resulted in recent contemporary French debates.
Key words: self, other, saturated phenomenon, call, giveness, donation, erotic reduction, love.
Full Text:
PDFReferences
Primary Sources (Marion)
1. Marion J.-L. Descartes’ Grey Ontology: Cartesian Science and Aristotelian Thought in the Regulae /J.-L. Marion; [tr. S. Donohue]. – South Bend: St. Augustine’s Press, 2004. – 320 p.
2. Marion J.-L. The Idol and Distance: Five Studies/ J.-L. Marion; [tr. T. A. Carlson]. – New York : Fordham University Press, 2001. – 257 p.
3. Marion J.-L. Sur la théologie blanche de Descartes. Analogie, création des vérités éternelles, fondement, / J.-L. Marion; – PUF : Paris, 1981. – 488 p.
4. Marion J.-L. God Without Being. Hors-Texte / J.-L. Marion; [tr. T. A. Carlson]. – Chicago and London : The University of Chicago Press, 2001. – 258 p.
5. Marion J.-L. On Descartes” Metaphysical Prism: The Constitution and the Limits of Onto-theo-logy in Cartesian Thought/ J.-L. Marion; [tr. J. L. Kosky]. – Chicago and London : The University of Chicago Press, 1999. – 388 p.
6. Marion J.-L. Prolégomènes à la charité/ J.-L. Marion; – Paris : Éditions de la Différence, 1986. – 180 p.
7. Marion J.-L. Questions cartésiennes II. Sur l’ego et sur Dieu / J.-L. Marion; – PUF : Paris, 1996. – 416 p.
8. Marion J.-L. Reduction and Givenness: Investigations of Husserl, Heidegger and Phenomenology/ J.-L. Marion; [tr. T. A. Carlson]. – Evanston : Northwestern University Press, 1998. – 261 p.
9. Marion J.-L. Cartesian Questions: Method and Metaphysics / J.-L. Marion; [tr. Varia]. – Chicago and London : The University of Chicago Press, 1999. – 215 p.
10. Marion J.-L. The Crossing of the Visible / J.-L. Marion; [tr. J. K. A. Smith]. – Stanford : Stanford University Press, 2004. – 120 p.
11. Marion J.-L. Being Given: Toward a Phenomenology of Givenness / J.-L. Marion; [tr. J. L. Kosky]. – Stanford : Stanford University Press, 2002. – 385 p.
12. Marion J.-L. In Excess: Studies of Saturated Phenomena / J.-L. Marion; [tr. R. HornerV. Berraud]. – New York : Fordham University Press, 2002. – 169 p.
13. Marion J.-L. Le Phénomène Érotique. Six Méditations / J.-L. Marion; – Paris : Grasset, 2003. – 373 p.
14. Marion J.-L. Dialogo con l’amore / J.-L. Marion; ed. Ugo Perone. – Torino : Rossemberg & Sellier, 2007. – 136 p.
15. Marion J.-L. The Visible and the Revealed / J.-L. Marion; [tr. C. M. Gschwander]. – New York : Fordham University Press, 2008. – 181 p.
16. Marion J.-L. In the Self’s Place: The Approach of St. Augustine / J.-L. Marion; [tr. J. L. Kosky]. – Stanford : Stanford University Press, 2012. – 414 p.
17. Marion J.-L. Sur la pensée passive de Descartes / J.-L. Marion; – Paris : PUF, 2013. – 288 p.
18. Marion J.-L. Negative Certainties, / J.-L. Marion; [tr. S. E. Lewis]. – Chicago and London : University of Chicago Press, 2015. – 288 p.
19. Marion J.-L. Givenness and Revelation (Gifford Lectures), / J.-L. Marion; [tr. S. E. Lewis]. – Oxford : Oxford University Press, 2016. – 137 p.
20. Marion J.-L. Reprise du donné / J.-L. Marion; – Paris : PUF, 2016. – 195 p.
21. Marion J.-L. The Rigor of Things. Conversations with Dan Arbib / J.-L. Marion; [tr. C. M. Gschwandtner]. – New York : Fordham University Press, 2017. – 187 p.
Articles and Contributions
22. Marion J.-L. Le sujet en dernier appel / J.-L. Marion // Revue de Métaphysique et de Morale. – 1991. – № 1 . – 77-95 p.
23. Marion J.-L. Métaphysique et phénoménologie : une relève pour la théologie. L’avenir de la métaphysique / J.-L. Marion // Bulletin de Littérature Ecclésiastique. – 1993. – № 94. – 189-206 p.
24. Marion J.-L. Le paradigme cartésien de la métaphysique / J.-L. Marion // Laval théologique et philosophique. – 1997. – № 53 . – 785-791 p.
25. Marion J.-L. La voix sans nom. Hommage - à partir - de Levinas / J.-L. Marion // Rue Descartes. – 1998. – № 19 . – 11-25 p.
26. Marion J.-L. The Saturated Phenomenon // Phenomenology and the “ Theological Turn ”. The French Debate. D. Janicaud-J.-F. Courtine-J.-L. Chrétien-M. HenryJ.-L. Marion-P. Ricœur: [tr. B. G. Prusak-J.L. Kosky-T.Q. Carlson]. – New York: Fordham University Press, 2000. – 176-216 p.
27. Marion J.-L. D’autrui è l’individu / Emmanuel Lévinas. Possibilité et transcendence / ed. J.-L. Marion ;– Paris : PUF, 2001. – 287-308 p.
28. Marion J.-L. The Event, the Phenomenon, and the Revealed // Transcendence in Philosophy and Religion / ed. by J. E. Faulconer; [tr. B. Starwaska]; – Bloomington and Indianapolis: Indiana University Press, 2003. – 87-105 p.
29. Marion J.-L. The Reason of the Gift // Giveness and God. Question of Jean-Luc Marion// ed. by I. Leask-E. Cassidy; [tr. S. Mackinlay-N. de Warren]; – New York: Fordham University Press, 2005. – 101-134 p.
30. Marion J.-L. – Kearney R. Hermeneutics of Revelation // After God. Richard Kearney and the Religious Turn in Continental Philosophy / ed. by J. P. Manoussakis; – New York: Fordham University Press, 2006. – 318-339 p.
31. Marion J.-L. La raison du don / Jean-Luc Marion // Philosophie. – 2003. – № 78. – 3-32 p.
32. Marion J.-L. Descartes hors sujet / J.-L. Marion // Les Études Philosophiques. – 2009. – № 1. – 51-62 p.
33. Jean-Luc Marion // Words of Life. New Theological Turns in French Phenomenology / ed. by B. E. Norman – N. Wirzba; – New York : Fordham University Press, 2010. – 89-131 p.
34. Marion J.-L. What love knowns // Love and Forgiveness for a More Just World / ed. by H. de Vries – N. F. Schott; – New York: Columbia University Press, 2015. – 27-35 p.
Secondary Sources
35. Alvis J. W. Marion and Derrida on The Gift and Desire : Debating the Generosity of Things / J. W. Alvis; – Heidelberg-New York-Dordrecht-London: Springer, 2016. – 269 p.
36. Agamben G. – Piazza V. L’Ombre de l’amour. Le concept d’amour chez Heidegger / G. Agamben – V. Piazza; – Paris : Rivage Poche. Petite Bibliothèque, 2003. – 107 p.
37. Alferi T. Dépasser la metaphysique… “ Au nom du Seigneur ! ” Philosophie et foi chrétienne selon Jean-Luc Marion / T. Alferi// Science et Esprit. – 2016. – № 68 . – 207–224 p.
38. Alliez E. De l’impossibilité de la phénoménologie. Sur La philosophie française contemporaine / E. Alliez; – Paris : Vrin, 1995. – 128 p.
39. Caldarone R. Caecus Amor. Jean-Luc Marion e la dismisura del fenomeno / R. Caldarone; – Pisa : Edizioni ETS, 2007. – 258 p.
40. Canullo C. L’Amore dell’Altro. Le phénomène Érotique di J.-L. Marion / C. Canullo // Studia Patavina. –2005. – № 52.– 489-528 p.
41. Derrida J. Giving Time: I. Counterfeit Money / J. Derrida; [tr. P. Kamuf]. Chicago and London : The University of Chicago Press, 1992. – 172 p.
42. Derrida J. La voix et le phénomène: Introduction au problème du signe dans la phénoménologie de Husserl / J. Derrida ; Paris : PUF, 2010. – 118 p.
43. Descartes R. Œuvres complètes, Correspondance : mai 1647 -- février 1650 / R. Descartes ; vol. V, ed. Ch. Adam – P. Tannery; Paris, Léopold Cerf, 1903 – 661 p.
44. Descartes R. Œuvres complètes, Meditationes de prima philosophia / R. Descartes ; vol. VII, ed. Ch. Adam – P. Tannery; Paris, Léopold Cerf, 1904 – 612 p.
45. Descartes R. Œuvres complètes, Meditationes de prima philosophia / R. Descartes ; vol. VII, ed. Ch. Adam – P. Tannery; Paris, Vrin, 1996 – 180 p.
46. De Vries H. The Passionate Utterance of Love. // Love and Forgiveness for a More Just World / ed. by H. de Vries – N. F. Schott; – New York: Columbia University Press, 2015. – 191-234 p.
47. Falque E. Phénoménologie de l’extraordinaire / E. Falque // Philosophie. – 2003. – № 78 . – 52–76 p.
48. Falque E. Le Haut Lieu du soi: une disputatio théologique et phénoménologique / E. Falque // Revue de Métaphysique et de Morale. – 2009. – № 3 . – 363–390 p.
49. Filonenko А. Jean-Luc Marion’s Philosophy of the Gift and Postmodern Culture / A. Filonenko // Logos: A Journal of Eastern Christian Studies. – 2006. – vol. 47, 1 – 2. – 219-228 p.
50. Gilbert P. Un tournant métaphysique dans la philosophie française ? M. Henry, J-L. Marion et P. Ricœur / P. Gilbert // Nouvelle Revue Théologique. – 2002. – № 124 . – 597–617 p.
51. Giveness and God. Question of Jean-Luc Marion// ed. by I. Leask-E. Cassidy; [tr. S. Mackinlay-N. de Warren]; – New York: Fordham University Press, 2005. – 346 p.
52. Marion. The Reason of the Gift // Transcendence in Philosophy and Religion / ed. by J. E. Faulconer; [tr. R. Hancock-J. Hancock-N. Hancock]; – Bloomington and Indianapolis: Indiana University Press, 2003. – 106-119 p.
53. Greisch J. L’herméneutique dans la “ phénoménologie comme tell ”. Trois questions à propos de Réduction et Donation / J. Greisch // Revue de Métaphysique et de Morale. – 1991. – № 1 – 43-63 p.
54. Haar M. La philosophie française entre phénoménologie et métaphysique / M. Haar ; Paris : PUF, 1999. – 158 p.
55. Henry M. Quatre principes de la phénoménologie / M. Henry // Revue de Métaphysique et de Morale. – 1991. – № 1 . – 3–26 p.
56. Henry M. Incarnation. Une philosophie de la chair / M. Henry; // Revue de Métaphysique et de Morale. – 1991. – № 1 . – 3–26 p.
57. Heidegger M. ., Sein und Zeit / M. Heidegger;Tübingen : Max Niemeyer Verlag, 2001. – 437 p.
58. Heidegger M. Identity and Difference / M. Heidegger;[tr. J. Stambaugh]; – New York : Harper and Row, 1969. – 76 p. 59. Horner R. Rethinking God as Gift. Marion, Derrida, and the Limits of Phenomenology / R. Horner;– New York : Fordham University Press, 2001. – 272 p.
60. Horner R. Jean-Luc Marion: ATheo-logical Introduction / R. Horner; – Burlington : Ashgate, 2005. – 222 p.
61. Janicaud D. The Theological Turn of French Phenomenology // Phenomenology and the “ Theological Turn ”. The French Debate. D. Janicaud. -J.-F. Courtine-J.-L. Chrétien-M. Henry-J.-L. Marion-P. Ricœur: [tr. B. G. Prusak-J.L. Kosky-T.Q. Carlson]. – New York: Fordham University Press, 2000. – 16-103 p.
62. Janicaud D. Phenomenology “Wide Open”. After the French Debate / D. Janicaud; [tr. C. N. Cabral]. – New York: Fordham University Press, 2005. – 105 p.
63. Jean-Luc Marion // Words of Life. New Theological Turns in French Phenomenology / ed. by B. E. Norman – N. Wirzba; – New York : Fordham University Press, 2010. – 89-131 p.
64. Gabe und Gemeinwohl: Die Unentgeltlichkeit in Ökonomie, Politik und Theologie: Jean-Luc Marions Phänomenologie in der Diskussion, eds. W. Schweidler, E. TardivelSchick, –Freiburg im Breisgau: Verlag Karl Alber, 2015. 160 p.
65. Gondek H.-D. – Tengelyi L. Neue Phänomenologie in Frankreich/ H.-D. Gondek– L. Tengelyi ; – Berlin: Suhrkamp Verlag, 2011. – 152-238; 352-387 p.
66. GschwandtnerC. M. Reading Jean-Luc Marion: Exceeding Metaphysics/ C. M. Gschwandtner; – Bloomington and Indianapolis: Indiana University Press, 2007.– 320 p.
67. GschwandtnerC. M. Degrees of Givenness. On Saturation in Jean-Luc Marion / C. M. Gschwandtner; – Bloomington and Indianapolis: Indiana University Press, 2014.– 279 p.
68. GschwandtnerC. M. Love as a Declaration of War? On the Absolute Character of Love in Jean-Luc Marion’s Phenomenology of Eros // Transforming Philosophy & Religion. Love’s Wisdom / – Bloomington and Indianapolis: Indiana University Press, 2008.– 185-198 p.
69. Kelly M. R.The Uses and Abuses of Husserl’s Doctrine of Immanence. The Specter of Spinozism in Phenomenology’s Theological Turn / M. R. Kelly //Heythrop Journal. – vol. 55, 4. – 553-564 p.
70. Mackinlay S. Interpreting Excess. Jean-Luc Marion, Saturated Phenomenon, and Hermeneutics / S. Mackinlay; – New York: Fordham University Press, 2010. – 283 p.
71. Medytatsiji Dekarta u dzerkali suchasnyh tlumachen: Jean-Luc Marion – Jean-Marie Beyssade –Kim Sang Ong-Van-Cung / J.-L. Marion, J.-M. Beyssade, K. S. Ong-VanCung; [tr. O. Khoma – A. Baumeister]. – Kiev : Dukh i Litera, 2014. – 23-91 p.
72. Nygren A. Agape and Eros/ A. Nygren; [tr. P. S. Watson]. – Chicago : University of Chicago Press, 1982. – 764 p.
73. On the Gift: A Discussion between Jacques Derrida and Jean-Luc Marion // God, the gift, and postmodernism / ed. by J. D. Сaputo – M. J. Scanlon; – Indianapolis: Indiana University Press, 1999. – 54-78 p.
74. Pseudo-Denys l’Aréopagite, Les noms divins / l’Aréopagite Pseudo-Denys; [tr. M. De Gandillac]. – Paris : Aubier Editions Montaigne, 1943. – 709B-709D, § 12, 106-107. p.
75. Romano C. L’événement et le monde / C. Romano; – Paris : PUF, 1998.– 336 p.
76. Saint Augustin, penseur du soi. Discussion de l’interprétation de Jean-Luc Marion // éd. E. Falque// Revue de Mйtaphysique et de Morale. – 2009. – № 3 . – 291–434 p.
77. Schrijvers J. Ontotheological Turnings. The Decentering of the Modern Subject in Recent French Phenomenology / J. Schrijvers; –New York: State University of New York, 2011. – 51-80.
78. Waldenfels B. Phänomenologie in Frankreich / B. Waldenfels ; – Berlin: Suhrkamp, 19872 . –576 p.
79. Westphal M. Vision and voice: Phenomenology and theology in work of Jean-Luc Marion / M. Westphal // International Journal for Philosophy of religion. – 2006.- № 60. – 117-137 p.
80. Wolf K. Philosophie der Gabe, Meditationen über die Liebe in der französischen Gegenwartsphilosophie / K. Wolf; – Stuttgart: Verlag W. Kohlhammer, 2006.– 196 p.
81. Words of Live. New Theological Turns in French Phenomenology / ed. B. E. Benson, N, Wirzba; – New York: Fordham University Press, 2010. – 272 p.
82. Zarader M. Phenomenality and Transcendence // Transcendence in Philosophy and Religion / ed. by J. E. Faulconer; [tr. R. Hancock-J. Hancock-N. Hancock]; – Bloomington and Indianapolis: Indiana University Press, 2003. – 106–119 p.
Refbacks
- There are currently no refbacks.
Lviv University Journal of Philosophy